4 Key Implications of Delaying the Nation’s Academic Report Card

What you need to know about the Department of Education's decision to delay the 2021 NAEP: America's most comprehensive tracker of educational development.

Share This Post

Share on facebook
Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on email

This week, the National Center for Education Studies announced they would delay the National Assessment of Education Progress, or the NAEP. Dubbed the Nation’s Report Card and known for their biennial national math and reading tests for fourth-, eighth-, and twelfth-grade students, the NAEP will now take place in 2022. 

According to their website, the NAEP is the “only assessment that measures what U.S. students know and can do in various subjects across the nation, states, and some urban districts.” The assessment, initiated in 1969, provides crucial insights for NCES officials, school administrators, and others who rely on the results to gauge trends in students’ learning of the core academic subjects and compare trends on a state-by-state basis. NAEP results do not provide individual student performance information, instead it informs us on how student groups are doing.  In a typical year, hundreds of thousands of fourth- and eighth-graders would be preparing to take this exam sometime between January and March.

Change in average scores between 2017 and 2019 for eighth-grade public school students assessed in NAEP reading, by state/jurisdiction: Source

The Commissioner of the NCES, James Woodworth, Ph.D., published the official statement on behalf of the NCES after the postponement was proposed by Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. Woodworth explained that the lack of physical attendance and increase in remote learning made it too difficult for the NAEP to get accurate results of student progress. Due to the many educational changes caused by  COVID-19,  results would also not be comparable to previous or future years of assessments. 

Cost-Benefit of Delaying NAEP

By postponing the nation’s education report card by one year, Woodworth hopes to allow school operations and student attendance to stabilize before conducting such a large-scale  assessment in order to get more reliable data. 

  1. Issue: Stress and Resources

Teachers and students are already presented with numerous obstacles to overcome due to COVID. Learning today, whether it be remote or socially distant, is different and therefore called for a transition period. Teachers are already challenged to cover all of their content, keep students engaged via a screen, and keep kids accountable with less supervision than ever before.

By delaying the assessment, Woodworth hopes to ease the workload of teachers. Furthermore, the delay will allow time for the states to conduct their own state assessments this spring.

  1. Issue: Financial Risk and Accuracy

Unlike state-level tests which are administered by school staff and measure student performance on the state-particular standards, The NAEP writes its own assessment and calls for outside proctoring. Running the NAEP assessments costs tens of millions of dollars—a cost well worth it if produces valid, nation-wide results. Unfortunately, as Woodworth claims, there is a clear risk this year of spending tens of millions of dollars only to receive inaccurate results.

Because testing occurs every other year, the next assessment couldn’t legally happen until 2023 without this postponement.

“Woodworth said a change in operations and lack of access for students to be assessed means that NAEP would not be able to produce estimates of students’ knowledge when compared to either past or future national or state estimates.”

  1. Issue: Pandemic Health Risks

This decision also decreases health risks in the midst of COVID. The Associated Press explained that the NCES sends proctors to conduct the NAEP assessments with shared equipment. Students would have to come to school to take the assessment. For the many schools that have transitioned to remote or blended learning this would appear to be counterproductive.  

Waiting a year eliminates the chance of putting students, teachers, assessment proctors, and the public health system at risk.

  • Counterpoint: Understanding the Pandemic’s Adverse Academic Effects

Some educational leaders advocated for the NAEP to take place because it could be a helpful way to better understand how the pandemic has  affected learning and education this year. Some experts also worry that without the NAEP assessment, a lot more pressure is placed on state-level assessments, which could also be cancelled like they were last spring under the federal waiving of state tests.

If states continue to skip annual assessments, they would just have a larger gap in data and little insight on how Covid-19 has affected learning, or the “COVID slide.”

Without the NAEP, How Else Can We Measure the “COVID-Slide”?

While we will have to wait an additional year for NAEP results, there are other organizations working to collect data on the “COVID-slide.”

These organizations share the goal to better understand how students are academically responding to this year’s educational environment. The Northwest Evaluation Association (NWEA), a nonprofit research group, is one of the leading groups working to collect reliable data on a national level using their own assessments. The NWEA’s trademark MAP Growth assessment (Measure of Academic Progress) in reading and math subjects has been used in thousands of school districts to measure student “growth and proficiency” of both in-person and remote learners, and can be used to provide insights into the “COVID-slide.”

The NWEA’s research-based project predicted that students in the fall of 2020 would lose 30-50% of their learning gains when compared with students in the same grade during the fall of 2019. These projections were based on seasonal learning loss, as well as “additional aspects of trauma to students, loss of resources, and loss of opportunity to learn” caused by the Covid-19 pandemic and school closures.

Projected Mathematics “COVID-Slide”: Source

Projected Reading “COVID-Slide”: Ibid

Not So Slippery After All

While the late-winter and early spring projections by the NWEA in 2020 painted a grim picture, recent empirical results by the organization indicate otherwise.

While the Northwest Evaluation Association projected students in grades 3 through 8 would lose about 30% of learning in reading and 50% in math compared to students in the fall of 2019, students in 2020 actually performed similarly in reading, and only lost about 5-10% of learning in math. NWEA summarized that “students showed growth in both reading and math achievement since the onset of COVID-19 disruptions, but growth in math was lower than in a typical year.” 

These findings are extremely helpful as schools evaluate how distance learning and the pandemic has affected their students’ progress. While taking the time to administer large scale testing might seem like a burden during this unpredictable year, the data collected from these assessments provide valuable insight in a truly unprecedented time that can help us learn where our students need a little extra help. 

Subscribe To Our Blog

Get updates and learn from The Juice Team!

More To Explore

Tips to Spark Conversations With Your Kids

If you’ve ever asked, “How was your day?” you know the one-word responses can be tiring. Inspire conversations at home and beyond with news that your kids want to talk about.

Why We Need to Teach Informational Text

Informational text not only helps diversify classroom content, but is crucial in preparing students to succeed in a society centered on information literacy.

Interested in The Juice?

Develop your students' critical thinking through current events, by joining our early access waitlist.

Need an account that can support more than 100 students? Just fill out this form and we'll get back to you with details shortly!

Sydney Teske

Social media and community manager

I earned my BA in Business Entrepreneurship and Innovation from the University of San Francisco, graduating Cum Laude while running Division 1 Track and Field. I continued my education at King’s College London, where I earned my MA in Cultural and Creative Industries.

I have experience in marketing, PR, and social media across several industries, including B2B tech, lifestyle, hospitality, digital advertising, and sports. I currently work as a digital marketing strategist for the New York Mets.

Outside of work I enjoy workout classes, travel, baseball (8 ballparks down, 22 to go), and reading as much as possible.

Need an account that can support more than 5 children? Just fill out this form and we'll get back to you with details shortly!

US Politics (Grades 11-12)

Biden Executive Orders Will Reverse Trump Policies

President-elect Joe Biden plans to sign a flurry of executive orders soon after his inauguration tomorrow. He plans to address what he’s calling the four crises facing the country. They are COVID-19, the economic downturn, racial injustice, and climate change.

An executive order is a written directive from the president carrying powers similar to a federal law. Presidents have historically used these orders to push policies forward quickly because they do not require approval from Congress. The downside of executive orders is that they are easily overturned by any new president. That is not true for federal laws.

Among other moves overturning Trump administration policies, Biden’s orders will return the US to the Paris Climate Accord and to the Iran nuclear deal.

Related to the pandemic, Biden will require face masks on federal properties and during interstate travel. Other orders will be aimed at safely reopening schools and businesses.

On immigration, Biden will order agencies to determine how to reunite children separated from their families after crossing the US-Mexico border. Another order will end travel restrictions targeting majority-Muslim countries.

Other orders will address “equity and support communities of color,” criminal justice reform, and access to healthcare.

Photo from Reuters.

Bold words are interactive vocab words in The Juice.

Play Video

Brendan Kells

VP, Education

After a career spent teaching students to become more sophisticated consumers of information in the classroom, I now serve as The Juice’s lead education specialist. I ensure our products are aligned with the educational promises we’ve made to the educational community.

Like many career educators, in addition to my 14 years as a classroom teacher at Cambridge Rindge and Latin, I served in many roles, including nine summers as the Principal of the Cambridge-Harvard Summer Academy. As a principal, teacher, mentor, advisor, and coach, I taught a wide range of subjects to a wide range of learners.

I earned my BA in History from Boston College and my Masters in teaching from Tufts University.

Robert Plotkin

CTO

I have over 30 years of experience in technology, software and Internet development. After starting my career building cutting-edge medical diagnostic equipment, I spent a decade at IBM’s T.J. Watson Research Center developing and programming a parallel supercomputer, then worked on interactive and Internet streaming-media technologies and large-scale database applications. After that, I worked at an early-stage Internet company developing streaming video content and have been involved in technology assessment for private equity, venture and public company investment for more than 15 years.

I have been developing web properties for public and private companies as well as for not-for-profits since the 2000’s. I am the holder of multiple patents and am published in peer-reviewed technology journals. I hold degrees from Columbia University’s School of Engineering (BSEE) and NYU Polytechnic (MSCS).

When not working or spending time with my family, I can be found playing violin with the Yonkers Philharmonic Orchestra, working on my golf game or pursuing my passion for photography.

You are now being directed to The Juice's publisher,
News and News.

Rated least-biased by Mediafactcheckbias.com

We’re glad you stopped by The Juice.

This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you visit. By using this website you consent to our use of these cookies. Find out more about how we use cookies and how to manage them by reading our Privacy Policy.